|
|
Post by FionnLoch on May 8, 2006 12:11:58 GMT -5
I hesitate to post this, 'cos I'm expecting a barrage of abuse, but are Shimano flyrods any good? I'm living in heathen territory and it's all my local tackle shop stocks: I need a rod in a hurry. They have the Biocraft XT and XTR. I'm not a great enthusiast for Japanese imitations meself, but any port in a storm...
|
|
|
|
Post by taggarc on May 8, 2006 15:55:10 GMT -5
I hesitate to post this, 'cos I'm expecting a barrage of abuse, but are Shimano flyrods any good? I'm living in heathen territory and it's all my local tackle shop stocks: I need a rod in a hurry. They have the Biocraft XT and XTR. I'm not a great enthusiast for Japanese imitations meself, but any port in a storm... For what's it is worth ... Trout fisherman in April 2006 tried and tested 24 bank rods, 7-8 weights, out of which 16 were chosen as TF recommended. The Biocrfat fly 79.99 failed to make the cut. In the up to 100 pound category the best scoring rod was the Diawa Wilderness with a score 87/100 (the best value commendation went to the Shakespeare oracle 52.00 pounds with a score 83/100) In the 100-300 pound category the Shimano Biocraft xt was the lowest cost rod by some margin, 104.99 pound. Just missing the cut-off point in the previous category. Conclusion " This rod feels so light you don't know it's in your hand. The wide line rating (6-8) is a bit unsettling but we found the 7wt was the ideal line to match this fastish middle to tip-actioned rod. Matt finish and quality cork handle make this a good rod for the price" Action 18/20 performance 17/20 Finnish 17/20 fittings 16/20 value for money 18/20 TF rating 86/100 Hope this is of use tag |
|
|
|
Post by beat3 on May 9, 2006 4:22:53 GMT -5
But then again I wouldn't put too much trust in a TF 'review'. Have seen some shockers in the past, usually appears to favour those who advertise. Just my opinion, no abuse please!
|
|
|
|
Post by 3lbgrayling on May 9, 2006 4:50:14 GMT -5
i bought the shimano exage travel rod.can't say i would recommend it .it's a bit dead,
jim
|
|
|
|
Post by Dapper on May 9, 2006 5:05:35 GMT -5
These rods are very good . I have had one for some years with no trouble.
By the way these rods are NOT Japanese , the one I had was marked " made in China".
Dapper
<*)))))
|
|
actinsley
Full Member
Chairman Spey Fishery Board Research Committee
Posts: 243
|
Post by actinsley on May 9, 2006 6:32:00 GMT -5
As of the last few years Shimano own Loomis, who make some of the best rods in the world, so I very much doubt that many Shimano rods are now that bad.
|
|
|
|
Post by beat3 on May 9, 2006 7:12:59 GMT -5
Never buy the telescopic ones, as far as cheap rod choice goes, buy online, then tell your local dealer who may respond by increasing his range....
|
|
|
|
Post by taggarc on May 9, 2006 14:06:03 GMT -5
But then again I wouldn't put too much trust in a TF 'review'. Have seen some shockers in the past, usually appears to favour those who advertise. Just my opinion, no abuse please! Thats why I introduced it as "for what's it worth". By the way they did bump the other Shimano rod, i.e. didn't give it a recommendation at all and did the same thing with a number of other manufacturers |
|
|
|
Post by beat3 on May 10, 2006 15:02:11 GMT -5
No dig intended, once pulled open a brand new telescopic one, broke it trying to close it!
|
|
|
|
Post by alan on May 10, 2006 19:43:10 GMT -5
Shimano built their name upon superb bearings and gears, so are fantastic at making fishing reels and bycycle stuff. Now how many gears/ball bearings are there in any of my rods; quick count across 8 fly rods 3 sea rods 3 coarse rods and a pole = answer nil.
Must be a next day delivery service by phone or internet to expand your choice.
|
|
tackletart
New Member
The man that likes quality tackle at a bargin price
Posts: 27
|
Post by tackletart on May 12, 2006 1:10:05 GMT -5
Dont be scared off by Simano they make some good gear and the finish is excellant.
I use a shimano for Hi d fishing as they are very powerful, a bit too heavy for floater fishing.
I'd say they are ok for stillwater fishing but not for boats.
Not sure what fishing you do?
T/tart
|
|
|
|
Post by FionnLoch on May 12, 2006 5:17:47 GMT -5
Not sure what fishing you do? I'm currently fishing for trout and grayling with nymphs and dries on heavily wooded streams in the Belgian Ardennes . I was looking for a very short rod. I've taken up Skinhead's offer of a Sharpe's Esse, which I have heard good things about on this forum. |
|
tackletart
New Member
The man that likes quality tackle at a bargin price
Posts: 27
|
Post by tackletart on May 12, 2006 5:34:04 GMT -5
Good choice for the type of fishing you do, nice fishing.
|
|
rusty
New Member
Posts: 49
|
Post by rusty on May 12, 2006 6:05:07 GMT -5
I hesitate to post this, 'cos I'm expecting a barrage of abuse, but are Shimano flyrods any good? I'm living in heathen territory and it's all my local tackle shop stocks: I need a rod in a hurry. They have the Biocraft XT and XTR. I'm not a great enthusiast for Japanese imitations meself, but any port in a storm... Why limit yourself to the local shop. I ordered a rod by phone and it was delivered by 10.00am the next morning, post included in the price. And it had come 300 miles. Do you want to revise the question? I suppose it is too late now! rusty |
|
